This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

Enjoy 25% off online orders 11/25-11/28! Discount automatically applies at checkout. Excludes engagement rings, watches, pre-owned designer, and previously discounted items.

Natural Diamond Engagement Rings

Natural Diamond Engagement Rings

Shop our selection of curated engagement rings made with natural, earth mined diamonds. Looking to create a custom engagement ring? Click below to get started!

Filter by

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $54,000.00 Reset
$
$
Clear all
  1. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.80 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.80 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.80 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.80 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond
    $14,000.00
  2. 3.20 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    3.20 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    3.20 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
    $37,700.00
  3. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.82 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.82 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.82 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.82 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.82 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.82 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond
    $9,700.00
  4. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.88 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.88 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.88 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.88 Oval Cut Natural Diamond
    Contact Us
    Inquire
  5. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.69 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.69 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.69 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.69 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond
    Contact Us
    Inquire
  6. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.52 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.52 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.52 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.52 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.52 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.52 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond
    Contact Us
    Inquire
  7. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.04 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.04 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.04 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.04 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.04 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.04 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond
    $28,200.00
  8. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.20 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.20 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.20 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.20 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.20 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.20 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond
    $5,400.00
  9. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.01 Radiant Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.01 Radiant Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.01 Radiant Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.01 Radiant Cut Natural Diamond
    Contact Us
    Inquire
  10. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.96 Princess Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.96 Princess Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.96 Princess Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.96 Princess Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.96 Princess Cut Natural Diamond
    $4,900.00
  11. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.08 Round Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.08 Round Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.08 Round Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.00 Round Natural Diamond
    $6,500.00
  12. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.50 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.50 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.50 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.50 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.50 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond
    $16,600.00
  13. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.17 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.17 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.17 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.17 Oval Cut Natural Diamond
    $22,000.00
  14. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.90 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.90 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.90 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 0.90 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond
    $6,200.00
  15. 3.00 Radiant Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    3.00 Radiant Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    3.00 Radiant Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
    Contact Us
    Inquire
  16. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.11 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.11 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.11 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.00 Marquise Cut Natural Diamond
    $6,400.00
  17. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.61 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.61 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.61 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.61 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.61 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.61 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.61 Pear Shape Natural Diamond
    Contact Us
    Inquire
  18. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.05 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.05 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.05 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.05 Round Brilliant Natural Diamond
    $7,900.00
  19. 2.01 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    2.01 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    2.01 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    2.01 Cushion Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
    $18,900.00
  20. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.01 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.01 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.01 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.01 Oval Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.01 Oval Cut Natural Diamond with Halo
    $49,000.00
  21. 1.73 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    1.73 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    1.73 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    1.73 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    1.73 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo
    $14,500.00
  22. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.00 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.00 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 3.00 Pear Shape Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    3.00 Pear Shape Natural Diamond Engagement Ring with Hidden Halo | Engagement Ring Wednesday
    Contact Us
    Inquire
  23. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.09 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.09 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.09 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 2.09 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday with Hidden Halo | 2.09 Emerald Cut Natural Diamond
    $18,200.00
  24. Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.12 Round Brilliant Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.12 Round Brilliant Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty
    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.12 Round Brilliant Cut Natural Diamond - Happy Jewelers Fine Jewelry Lifetime Warranty

    Engagement Ring Wednesday | 1.12 Round Brilliant Cut Natural Diamond
    Contact Us
    Inquire